The American highway lobby contends that the road versus rail tension in American life is, and should be, solely a creature of the marketplace. It is remarkable then that Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Republican governor of California, has injected government into the debate in a gesture so striking that the auto industry, including Ford Motor Company President William Clay Ford, is up in arms. The New York Times reports that California will open its HOV lanes to single-occupant cars which attain a fuel efficiency of 45 miles per gallon or more, a policy move benefitting largely the Toyota Prius. Mr. Ford tells The Times the governor might as well promote a "Buy Japanese" campaign.
Actually it's a myth that the struggle for primacy in surface transportation is a free market affair. For more than a century now, government has weighed in in a big way. The Brookings Institution, for instance, estimates that trucks pay for only about 14 per cent of the true expenses their presence on the American roads costs taxpayers. People choose cars over trains, in part, because government subsidizes cars and driving so heavily. Should the public be grateful to government for subsidizing the cost of roads and starving the rails? Hardly, because what Washington appears to put into our one pocket, it takes out of the other, through a raft of other property, sales, excise and other taxes. Congress, in fact, spends $62 on interstate highways alone for each $1 it spends on the rails.
A century ago, when the federal government tired of the rapacious rails, it sought to sell the idea of building roads to a wary public through what it innocently called "propaganda." It set up demonstration road projects in the hinterlands, so Farmer Brown could see what a treat it was to walk Bessie over a paved surface. It sponsored essay contests for children and scholarships for the college bound interested in a career in road engineering. History Wire's own Steve Goddard has written a panoramic account of this phenomenon in Getting There: The Epic Struggle Between Road and Rail in the American Century, which has gone through four printings and is now available in paperback.