What Happened -- Inside the Bush White House and Washington's Culture of Deception by Scott McClellan, PublicAffairs '08, $27.95, 341 pages, ISBN #978-1-58648-556-6. Index, no bibliography or source notes, grouping of b&w glossy images.
To some, Scott McClellan's tell-all memoir of his White House days, including a stint as press secretary, seems an opportunistic, even cynical, ploy to cash in by trashing the most unpopular presidential administration in generations. But that's not how it reads.
McClellan comes from a distinguished Texas family, particularly on his mother's side. His grandfather, Page Keeton, was a near-legendary law dean at the University of Texas and authored a textbook on tort law that, for decades, was nearly equal in stature to Paul Samuelson's Economics 101 textbook. His mother, Carole Keeton Strayhorn, served three terms as mayor of Austin, TX, and as state comptroller for public accounts.
By his telling, McClellan went to work for Gov. George Bush while in his 20s and found him to be "a uniter, not a divider," the kind of politician who readily crosses the party aisle to get things accomplished. Sensing this is the kind of president America needs, the young idealist followed Bush to the White House. Bush may or may not have been the kind of healer McClellan describes; Scott wouldn't be the first starstruck political aide who overlooks a leader's flaws in idolizing the man who hired him. And as many have written, the narrowly-defined job of Texas governor is a layup.
Enter Karl Rove and Dick Cheney, two men for whom McClellan has little good to say. He is critical of the runup to the Iraq war, the WMD kerfuffle, and the Valerie Plame outing for reasons that have become conventional wisdom. And while he feels strongly that Bush himself didn't know Saddam Hussein lacked weapons of mass destruction when he invaded Iraq and expresses affection for the president as a person, he praises almost nothing Bush has done as president.
Interestingly, McClellan's outlook and worldview is one with which most Democrats would feel comfortable. Perhaps that's because his family's roots lie with the Democratic Party. The Keetons are among millions of Southerners who jumped the political fence in the wake of Lyndon Johnson's support of civil rights legislation in the 1960s. All in all, McClellan's book is a worthwhile, substantive addition to the history of the American presidency.